[R-SIG-Mac] Which command line tools for XCode 4.2.1

[cstrato]

Dear Prof. Ripley,

Thank you for this extensive information.

You mention that you have been working hard on making R and CRAN 
packages installable using clang, which is quite an effort.

Currently, the Bioconductor maintainers are doing the same, i.e. 
checking which BioC packages are installable using clang, and I was 
informed that my package 'xps' cannot be installed using clang.

In my case the main problem seems to be that the version of clang used 
has a bug which prevents compilation of xps (and the necessary ROOT C++ 
framework).

Concretely, both the Bioconductor server running Snow Leopard and my 
Snow Leopard Mac have versions of Xcode, which include clang Version 
3.0. In order to compile ROOT successfully, at least clang Version 3.1 
is necessary, see:
http://root.cern.ch/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=14614#p62969

On my Mac running Lion (10.7.5) I have currently also installed Xcode 
4.2.1 which contains clang Version 3.0, so I could reproduce this error 
also on Lion. After downloading the the 'Command Line Tools (OS X Lion) 
for Xcode - March 2013' from the Apple developer site the version of 
clang is now:
$ clang -v
Apple LLVM version 4.2 (clang-425.0.27) (based on LLVM 3.2svn)
Target: x86_64-apple-darwin11.4.2

Using this version I could successfully compile both ROOT and xps. The 
problem is that I do not know how to obtain a more recent version of 
clang for Snow Leopard, the system currently running on the BioC server.

I would very much appreciate if you could propose a solution for this 
problem.

Thank you in advance.
Best regards,
Christian


On 4/18/13 11:03 AM, Prof Brian Ripley wrote:
>  > Since I have heard that R and Bioconductor packages should in the future
>  > be built with clang since Apple will be discontinuing support of gcc, my
>  > question is:
>
> I've not heard that, and you give no reference.  It's a pretty safe
> prediction except for timing: it could be a year away.  So your
> questions are not relevant until it is announced.  The documentation in
> the current R manuals is currently the correct advice.
>
> Apple have announced the imminent discontinuation of llvm-gcc, and we
> take that to mean it will not be in Xcode 4.7 (or 5.0 if that is
> released first).  That would mean that once that is released, for most
> users of Lion and later llvm-gcc will disappear (as most users will get
> an automatic upgrade from the AppStore, or as in my case, the sysadmins
> will push out an update).
>
> So we have been working hard on making R and CRAN packages installable
> using clang (there were too many problems at decision time for 3.0.0).
> How to switch a CRAN binary installation to use clang[++] is in the R >=
> 3.0.0 manuals.  That may not work for packages with configure scripts:
> for that you may need R-patched.
>
> There are now only seven CRAN packages which have bugs which stop
> installation under clang, and all the maintainers have been sent
> patches.  (Two of those do not install under gcc 4.8.0 either.)
>
> Very likely at some point Simon will switch the CRAN binary distribution
> to use clang, but the real point is that many end-users will need to do
> so soon.
>
> Given that R 3.0.0 supports OS 10.6 (Snow Leopard), it is likely that we
> will do so for all of the 3.0.x series, even though 10.6 will almost
> certainly reach end-of-life well before 3.1.0 is due.  In that case the
> CRAN builder could stick with llvm-gcc for that series, but it may prove
> more convenient for end-users to switch to the distribution to clang
> before then.  Only time will tell.
>
>
> On 17/04/2013 18:45, cstrato wrote:
>> Dear Prof. Ripley, dear Simon,
>>
>> Thank you for this information about Xcode and CLTs.
>>
>> Since I have heard that R and Bioconductor packages should in the future
>> be built with clang since Apple will be discontinuing support of gcc, my
>> question is:
>>
>> - Which version of Xcode and/or CLTs should Snow Leopard users install
>> in the future? (the last official version for Snow Leopard is
>> xcode_3.2.6)
>>
>> - Which version of Xcode and/or CLTs should Lion/Mountain Lion users
>> install so that they can still compile their packages with gcc, too?
>> (the current version is xcode_4.6.2)
>>
>>  From the discussion I understand that it is no longer necessary to
>> install Xcode at all, installing CLTs is sufficient. Is this  correct?
>>
>> Best regards,
>> Christian
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> R-SIG-Mac mailing list
>> R-SIG-Mac at r-project.org
>> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-mac
>
>