[R] Taking code from packages
murdoch at stats.uwo.ca
Fri Jan 13 13:46:08 CET 2006
On 1/13/2006 2:04 AM, Ales Ziberna wrote:
> I am currently in the process of creating (my first) package, which (when
> ready) I intend to publish to CRAN. In the process of creating this package
> I have taken some code form existing packages. I have actually copied parts
> of functions in to new functions. This code is usually something very basic
> such as Rand index. What is the proper procedure for this?
> Since most of R (and also the packages I have taken code form) is published
> under GPL, I think this should be OK. However I do not know if:
> 1. I should still ask authors of the packages for permission or at
> least notify them.
It is polite to notify them.
> 2. Ad references to the functions (and packages) from which I had taken
> the code or only to the references they use.
The GPL requires that you maintain their copyright notices. You have
the right to use their work, the GPL doesn't give you ownership of it.
The usual way to do this is to leave their copyright notice intact, and
add your own if you have made modifications.
An alternative which is usually (but not always) better is to say that
your package depends on theirs, and then just use their functions. The
advantage is that it avoids any of the above mixed copyright issues, and
it makes sure that when the author fixes a bug, you benefit too. The
disadvantage is that it makes your package dependent on theirs, so if
changes are needed in it for some future version of R, you'll have to
wait for the other maintainer to do them (or copy their code at that point).
(I'm a little sensitive about dependencies now, since the LaTeX seminar
template I've used a few times no longer works. It depends on too many
LaTeX packages, and someone, somewhere has introduced incompatibilities
in them. Seems like I'll be forced to use Powerpoint or Impress.)
> What about regarding code that was sent to the list, usually as a response
> to one of my problems. I assume that in this case it is best to consult the
> Any comments and opinions are very welcomed!
> Best regards,
> Ales Ziberna
> R-help at stat.math.ethz.ch mailing list
> PLEASE do read the posting guide! http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
More information about the R-help