[R-sig-ME] Problems fitting GLMM and getting AIC

[Mario Garrido]

Dear lme4-users,
I am trying to fit my data to a generalized linear model with repeated
measures. My data consists on the relative amount of bacterial colonies in
hosts' blood provided by qPCR (qpcr.bart), I measure the amount of qpcr.bart at
7 different time points (day) for each of the 19 individuals (exp.ID).
As random
factor I use (1 | exp.ID). At time zero all the values are 0 cause the
indivuals were still not infected.
As a fixed factor, I also include treatment (trtmnt): whether animals were
infected with 1 bacteria (Bartonella) or 2 (coinfected with another)

Attach is my data. I want to fit my data to different model distributions
(even if I know in advance that are not the correct distributionss) then
compare between them using AICc, as some reviewers asked me

#I have no problem to fit the model to *Gaussian*. even if I know that my
distribution is not normal, as analyses of the residuals show.
lmer(qpcr.bart ~ day * trtmnt + (1 | exp.ID)) ->mgauss

#I get an error when trying to fit to *Gamma*, even if I add 1 to
qpcr.bart cause
Gamma not accept zeroes
glmer((qpcr.bart+1) ~ day * trtmnt + ( 1 | exp.ID), family = Gamma) ->mGamma
Error in (function (fr, X, reTrms, family, nAGQ = 1L, verbose = 0L, maxit =
100L,  :
  (maxstephalfit) PIRLS step-halvings failed to reduce deviance in
pwrssUpdate

*Q1:* is this error due to the low variability in the data and the use of
too many parameters?

#By round the numbers and avoid integers (dezimals) I can consider data as
count data and fit to *Poisson*. I also have the following problems and, in
addition, I do not know whether I can extract AIC or any other I-T index
glmer(round(qpcr.bart,digits=0) ~ day * trtmnt + ( 1 | exp.ID), family =
poisson) ->mPoisson
Warning messages:
1: In checkConv(attr(opt, "derivs"), opt$par, ctrl = control$checkConv,  :
  Model failed to converge with max|grad| = 0.00263583 (tol = 0.001,
component 1)
2: In checkConv(attr(opt, "derivs"), opt$par, ctrl = control$checkConv,  :
  Model is nearly unidentifiable: very large eigenvalue
 - Rescale variables?;Model is nearly unidentifiable: large eigenvalue ratio
 - Rescale variables?

*Q2:* What this error meaning? I know I have overdispersion, but how to
deal with it? is this problem related with overdispersion?

#Lastly, if I accept that I have overdispersion I can go to Quasi approac
(but do not give me AIC) or try to converge to *negative binomial *using
glmer.nb from MASS.
glmer.nb(qpcr.bart ~ day * trtmnt + ( 1 | exp.ID))
Also I have 50 or more warnings
Mainly these ones
 1: In checkConv(attr(opt, "derivs"), opt$par, ctrl = control$checkConv,
... :
  Model failed to converge with max|grad| = 0.00263583 (tol = 0.001,
component 1)
2: In checkConv(attr(opt, "derivs"), opt$par, ctrl = control$checkConv,
... :
  Model is nearly unidentifiable: very large eigenvalue
 - Rescale variables?;Model is nearly unidentifiable: large eigenvalue ratio
 - Rescale variables?
3: In theta.ml(Y, mu, weights = object at resp$weights, limit = limit,  ... :
  iteration limit reached
4: In sqrt(1/i) : NaNs produced

*Q3:* At this point I am totally lost, what is the problem?

*Q4:* Another question regarding the random factor: What is the meaning of
using (day | exp.ID) instead of (1 | exp.ID) as a random factor?

Thanks, here is my data


*exp ID* *BM* *day* *qpcr bart* *trtmnt *
EA115 35.15 0 0 coinfection
EA115 33.51 11 24100 coinfection
EA115 35.01 21 10700 coinfection
EA115 35.34 31 1580 coinfection
EA115 30.89 42 228 coinfection
EA115 32.98 52 8.75 coinfection
EA115 33.56 63 23.9 coinfection
EA100 40.18 0 0 coinfection
EA100 41.64 11 1710000 coinfection
EA100 42.23 21 2830 coinfection
EA100 42.4 31 245 coinfection
EA100 43.03 42 5.81 coinfection
EA100 43.35 52 0 coinfection
EA100 44.32 63 16 coinfection
EA109 41.12 0 0 coinfection
EA109 39.98 11 1440000 coinfection
EA109 39.9 21 6710 coinfection
EA109 41.23 31 28.9 coinfection
EA109 41.58 42 10.8 coinfection
EA109 42.1 52 0 coinfection
EA109 42.38 63 14.1 coinfection
EA91 33.31 0 0 coinfection
EA91 33.74 11 752000 coinfection
EA91 32.68 21 3850 coinfection
EA91 34.21 31 1460 coinfection
EA91 33.29 42 28.6 coinfection
EA91 34.38 52 0 coinfection
EA91 34.05 63 10.6 coinfection
EA86 38.56 11 18600 coinfection
EA86 38.01 21 11300 coinfection
EA86 37.63 0 0 coinfection
EA86 38.5 31 74.4 coinfection
EA86 38.68 42 7.18 coinfection
EA86 38.93 52 0 coinfection
EA86 38.45 63 20 coinfection
EA90 51.94 0 0 coinfection
EA90 50.59 11 1000000 coinfection
EA90 50.19 21 4030 coinfection
EA90 51.34 31 134 coinfection
EA90 51.17 42 11.7 coinfection
EA90 52.54 52 0 coinfection
EA90 52.48 63 15 coinfection
EA102 36.54 0 0 coinfection
EA102 37.37 11 1270000 coinfection
EA102 37.49 21 12200 coinfection
EA102 38.34 31 2040 coinfection
EA102 36.51 42 35.2 coinfection
EA102 37.23 52 8.19 coinfection
EA102 37.57 63 0 coinfection
EA104 40.37 0 0 coinfection
EA104 38.74 11 1020000 coinfection
EA104 39.48 21 8910 coinfection
EA104 40.81 31 2530 coinfection
EA104 39.37 42 26.9 coinfection
EA104 40.78 52 14.4 coinfection
EA104 40.96 63 0 coinfection
EA116 33.31 0 0 coinfection
EA116 32.85 11 442000 coinfection
EA116 33.29 21 7840 coinfection
EA116 34.06 31 1890 coinfection
EA116 33.92 42 204 coinfection
EA116 34.39 52 14.5 coinfection
EA116 34.42 63 14.5 coinfection
EA118 40.06 0 0 coinfection
EA118 40.78 11 330000 coinfection
EA118 41.66 21 1790 coinfection
EA118 42.06 31 153 coinfection
EA118 42.17 42 7.09 coinfection
EA118 42.28 52 12.5 coinfection
EA118 43.07 63 13.7 coinfection
EA96 34.39 0 0 Bart
EA96 33.94 11 1930000 Bart
EA96 34.65 21 1500 Bart
EA96 35.66 31 16.6 Bart
EA96 32.8 42 0 Bart
EA96 32.22 52 13.3 Bart
EA96 33.01 63 11.8 Bart
EA92 45.53 0 0 Bart
EA92 47.55 11 0 Bart
EA92 47.81 21 13000 Bart
EA92 48.38 31 750 Bart
EA92 47.33 42 18.7 Bart
EA92 47.37 52 0 Bart
EA92 47.27 63 18.6 Bart
EA97 35.42 0 0 Bart
EA97 33.37 11 480000 Bart
EA97 33.02 21 4200 Bart
EA97 34.88 31 17.9 Bart
EA97 34.63 42 0 Bart
EA97 34.88 52 0 Bart
EA97 34.75 63 11.2 Bart
EA119 45.31 0 0 Bart
EA119 42.72 11 468000 Bart
EA119 43.31 21 2320 Bart
EA119 44.06 31 59.4 Bart
EA119 44.6 42 9.56 Bart
EA119 43.51 52 0 Bart
EA119 45.08 63 0 Bart
EA112 40.15 0 0 Bart
EA112 39.54 11 1650000 Bart
EA112 39.43 21 3190 Bart
EA112 40.72 31 15.7 Bart
EA112 38.94 42 0 Bart
EA112 38.8 52 0 Bart
EA112 38.42 63 19.1 Bart
EA93 30.54 0 0 Bart
EA93 29.32 11 892000 Bart
EA93 28.89 21 7940 Bart
EA93 28.77 31 36.7 Bart
EA93 27.92 42 14.8 Bart
EA93 28.71 52 0 Bart
EA93 28 63 14.9 Bart
EA114 46.01 0 0 Bart
EA114 41.42 11 0 Bart
EA114 41.09 21 4780 Bart
EA114 41.7 31 18.6 Bart
EA114 41.78 42 17.4 Bart
EA114 41.91 52 6.24 Bart
EA114 43.01 63 20.7 Bart
EA120 41.86 0 0 Bart
EA120 40.95 11 1110000 Bart
EA120 41.19 21 6450 Bart
EA120 41.96 31 8.2 Bart
EA120 41.66 42 0 Bart
EA120 41.86 52 10.3 Bart
EA120 41.15 63 14.5 Bart
EA105 32.4 0 0 Bart
EA105 34.35 11 1850000 Bart
EA105 34.53 21 13800 Bart
EA105 34.82 31 1290 Bart
EA105 33.8 42 64.4 Bart
EA105 35.13 52 14.7 Bart
EA105 34.44 63 17.7 Bart
EA82 36.86 0 0 Bart
EA82 36.84 11 698000 Bart
EA82 36.24 21 1470 Bart
EA82 37.11 31 10.4 Bart
EA82 36 42 0 Bart
EA82 36.3 52 5.23 Bart
EA82 36.53 63 15.1 Bart

	[[alternative HTML version deleted]]