references year plant type species seed mass mg drougth day control sd.control n.control experiment sd.experiment n.experiment Sigala et al. 2020 2020 conifer Pinus ponderosa 36,6 56 46,43 2,63 36 87,71 1,744 36 Robakowski et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Fagus sylvatica 234 43 46,19 11,16 16 90,51 45,68 16 Robakowski et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Quercus petraea 2342,2 43 47,73 19,08 16 74,83 5,44 16 Robakowski et al. 2020 2020 conifer Abies alba 60,2 43 57,27 10,24 16 53,18 4,76 16 Robakowski et al. 2020 2020 conifer Pinus sylvestris 6 43 48,75 12,96 16 47,89 22,52 16 Aalipour et al. 2020 2020 conifer Cupressus arizonica 7,88 150 0,241 0,03 9 0,436 0,06 9 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 0 99,99 3,33 6 86,48 3,3 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 1 89,18 9,94 6 108,11 9,94 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 2 95,94 6,61 6 144,59 3,3 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 4 114,86 2,47 6 182,43 13,25 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 6 132,43 6,61 6 198,64 3,3 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 8 143,24 3,3 6 224,32 6,61 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 10 105,4 3,3 6 175,67 9,8 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Schima superba 4,2 12 159,46 3,3 6 175,67 6,63 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 0 56,25 6,56 6 72,32 6,54 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 1 85,71 3,28 6 140,65 16,33 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 2 124,55 3,15 6 136,6 16,41 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 4 116,51 3,28 6 148,66 9,82 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 6 116,51 3,28 6 195,53 16,41 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 8 145,98 3,28 6 223,66 3,28 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 10 112,5 6,54 6 194,19 6,56 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Castanopsis fissa 1155 12 97,77 3,25 6 176,78 6,56 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 0 60,81 9,9 6 75,67 6,6 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 1 77,02 6,6 6 118,91 3,3 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 2 131,08 6,6 6 151,35 3,3 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 4 148,64 2,35 6 191,89 6,6 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 6 171,62 13,22 6 222,97 2,44 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 8 121,62 3,3 6 231,08 13,25 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 10 105,4 3,3 6 216,21 6,6 6 Zhang et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Michelia macclurei 46,5 12 109,45 6,6 6 194,59 13,25 6 Sun et al. 2020 2020 deciduous Prunus persica 3333,3 12 17,95 1,37 3 30,91 0,91 3 Santos et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Hevea brasiliensis 3809 32 1,74 0,32 4 10,21 1,22 4 Tatari et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Pyrus salicifolia 52,3181 120 11,03 1,15 10 80,97 1,29 10 Tatari et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Pyrus communis cv. Spadona 32 120 8,59 1,44 10 56,89 1,29 10 Tatari et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Pyrus syriaca 84,43 120 9,17 1,14 10 69,07 1,15 10 Ghanbary et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Quercus infectoria 6430 365 3,62 0,23 3 4,74 0,54 3 Ghanbary et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Quercus libani 1000 365 3,96 0,008 3 4,21 0,23 3 Galeano et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Tectona grandis 696,37 30 82,08 31,67 5 279,36 123,11 5 Lin et al. 2019 2019 conifer Torreya grandis 9000 90 11,49 0,83 6 14,2 0,53 6 Xiu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Malus halliana 15 3 51,06 12,19 3 61,17 11,05 3 Xiu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Malus halliana 15 6 51,06 12,19 3 75,53 12,88 3 Xiu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Malus halliana 15 9 51,06 12,19 3 111,7 11,05 3 Xiu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Malus halliana 15 12 51,06 12,19 3 146,8 12,92 3 Xiu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Malus halliana 15 15 51,06 12,19 3 164,89 12,9 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 4 26,45 12,83 3 41,79 13,75 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 8 26,45 12,83 3 65,08 12,83 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 12 26,45 12,83 3 99,47 2,74 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 16 26,45 12,83 3 109,52 7,34 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 20 26,45 12,83 3 208,47 26,57 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 24 26,45 12,83 3 217,99 75,15 3 Wu et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Cinnamomum burmannii 97,3 28 26,45 12,83 3 197,35 18,34 3 Plesa et al. 2018 2018 conifer Larix decidua 5,88 30 8,23 1,83 7 9,56 2,98 7 Tariq et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Alnus cremastogyne 1,2 90 0,02 0,006 3 0,04 0,01 3 Jafarania et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Quercus brantii 1060 90 3,97 0,74 4 9,39 0,72 4 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 1 2,84 1 5 2,56 1,21 5 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 4 2,83 1,23 5 7,86 1,63 5 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 9 3,65 1,25 5 15,27 2,46 5 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 13 3,75 1,25 5 17,65 2,2 5 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 16 4,57 1,43 5 35,03 4,89 5 Kebbas et al. 2018 2018 deciduous Gleditsia triacanthos 168,6 19 6,49 1,03 5 55,97 1,83 5 Merz et al. 2017 2017 deciduous Quercus garryana 4369,36 42 26,88 0,56 4 46,47 3,69 4 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Sophora viciifolia 21,78 1 335,66 16,79 15 358,04 22,38 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Sophora viciifolia 21,78 7 335,66 16,79 15 475,52 16,79 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Sophora viciifolia 21,78 14 335,66 16,79 15 1611,18 22,39 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Sophora viciifolia 21,78 21 335,66 16,79 15 1795,8 8,4 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Hippophae rhamnoides 38 1 179,02 16,79 15 184,61 39,16 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Hippophae rhamnoides 38 7 179,02 16,79 15 111,89 16,78 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Hippophae rhamnoides 38 14 179,02 16,79 15 167,83 11,19 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Hippophae rhamnoides 38 21 179,02 16,79 15 257,34 16,79 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Berberis hemsleyana 10 1 167,83 11,19 15 167,88 11,19 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Berberis hemsleyana 10 7 167,83 11,19 15 330,07 22,38 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Berberis hemsleyana 10 14 167,83 11,19 15 587,41 11,19 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Berberis hemsleyana 10 21 167,83 11,19 15 665,73 5,6 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Betula platyphylla 0,1 1 142,66 13,98 15 162,24 13,98 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Betula platyphylla 0,1 7 142,66 13,98 15 285,31 27,97 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Betula platyphylla 0,1 14 142,66 13,98 15 307,69 11,19 15 Guo et al. 2016 2016 deciduous Betula platyphylla 0,1 21 142,66 13,98 15 262,94 11,19 15 Yaish et al. 2015 2015 deciduous Phoenix dactylifera 1076 14 3,51 0,37 6 4,64 0,22 6 Zhang et al. 2014 2014 deciduous Cyclobalanopsis glauca 526,32 90 0,0181 0,003 10 0,026 0,003 10 Filippou et al. 2014 2014 deciduous Ailanthus altissima 29,4 14 14,95 1,4 3 40,04 2,68 3 Wu et al. 2013 2013 deciduous Quercus variabilis 4364,23 30 39,43 1,4 6 64,04 4,95 6 Wu et al. 2013 2013 deciduous Quercus variabilis 4364,23 60 42,02 6,6 6 74,16 2,2 6 Wu et al. 2013 2013 deciduous Quercus variabilis 4364,23 90 45,84 4,4 6 61,79 1,47 6 Wu et al. 2013 2013 deciduous Quercus variabilis 4364,23 120 46,29 3,3 6 52,69 4,14 6 Zhang et al. 2013 2013 deciduous Malus robusta 26,681 30 1,23 0,28 8 2,23 0,25 8 Cavatte et al. 2011 2011 deciduous Coffea arabica 188,3 240 1,7 0,22 5 2,8 0,22 5 Li et al. 2011 2011 deciduous Broussonetia papyrifera 2,1 11 0,35 0,08 3 6,1 0,2 3 OsĂłrio et al. 2011 2011 deciduous Ceratonia siliqua 181 15 25,21 7,62 5 5,34 11,94 5 Arji and Arzani 2008 2008 deciduous Olea europaea 250 90 5,95 1,08 4 11,23 1,49 4 Qu et al. 2019 2019 deciduous Camellia oleifera 508 60 37,77 2,91 3 100,36 3,99 3 Wang et al. 2019 2019 conifer Pinus massoniana 13,55 0 197,52 58,16 5 180,8 18 5 Wang et al. 2019 2019 conifer Pinus massoniana 13,55 7 191,95 8,3 5 204,33 9,7 5 Wang et al. 2019 2019 conifer Pinus massoniana 13,55 28 187,61 12,45 5 372,76 66,46 5