[R] suggestion for proportions
cesar.rabak at gmail.com
Thu Sep 8 02:31:13 CEST 2011
Em 7/9/2011 16:53, array chip escreveu:
> Hi all, thanks very much for sharing your thoughts. and sorry for my describing the problem not clearly, my fault.
> My data is paired, that is 2 different diagnostic tests were performed on the same individuals. Each individual will have a test results from each of the 2 tests. Then in the end, 2 accuracy rates were calculated for the 2 tests. And I want to test if there is a significant difference in the accuracy (proportion) between the 2 tests. My understanding is that prop.test() is appropriate for 2 independent proportions, whereas in my situation, the 2 proportions are not independent calculated from "paired" data, right?
> the data would look like:
> pid test1 test2
> p1 1 0
> p2 1 1
> p3 0 1
> 1=test is correct; 0=not correct
> from the data above, we can calculate accuracy for test1 and test2, then to compare....
> So mcnemar.test() is good for that, right?
From above clarifying I suggest you consider the use of kappa test. For
a list of possible ways of doing it in R try:
More information about the R-help