[R] sub question
Waclaw.Marcin.Kusnierczyk at idi.ntnu.no
Tue Feb 3 14:24:18 CET 2009
Peter Dalgaard wrote:
> Gabor Grothendieck wrote:
>> On Sat, Jan 31, 2009 at 6:01 PM, Wacek Kusnierczyk
> th some additional boring pedantry wrt. ?gsubfn, which says:
>>> " If 'replacement' is a formula instead of a function then a one
>>> line function is created whose body is the right hand side of the
>>> formula and whose arguments are the left hand side separated by
>>> '+' signs (or any other valid operator). The environment of the
>>> function is the environment of the formula. If the arguments are
>>> omitted then the free variables found on the right hand side are
>>> used in the order encountered. "
>>> to my little mind, all of 'paste', 'rep', 'nchar', and 'x' in the
>>> example above are *free variables* on the right of the formula. you
>> The first three are functions, not variables.
> They are still free variables, subject to the same rules of variable
> lookup. Wacek is right: The RHS is scanned recursively for objects of
> mode "name" _except_ when they appear as function names (i.e. if
> subexpression e is mode "call", then forget e[] and look at the
> arguments in as.list(e)[-1]. Not sure if this also happens if e[]
> is not a name, e.g. in f(a)(b), do you get both a and b or just b?)
an interesting point. the two calls to gsubfn below should, in this
particular case, be equivalent:
f = function(a) function(b) paste(a, b, sep="")
gsubfn('o', ~ f('o')(o), 'foo')
gsubfn('o', ~ f(o)('o'), 'foo')
# the match seems to be ignored in the formula?
the following fails, too:
f = function(a) function() paste(a, a, sep="")
gsubfn('o', ~ f(o)(), 'foo')
# o won't capture the match
this as well, though it's rather different:
f = function() 'oo'
gsubfn('o', ~ f(), 'foo')
# really can't ignore the matched pattern if a formula is given?
while an average statistician may never write such rubbish code, these
are trivialized examples, and for a language advertised as one from the
functional family this sort of code is not so unusual and it may be
surprising that it fails.
More information about the R-help